Skip to content
MakerGain
← Back to cases

Average Rank Went from 14.0 to 6.5, but Clicks Fell from 101,890 to 94,167

Edited by MakerGainPublished: Article updated:

AEO Engine ties the content calendar, publishing, and GA4/GSC access into a contract that starts at 90 days and bills monthly; it uses senior strategists plus more than 40 AI agents to handle AI search visibility for brands. In the Broadview case, impressions rose to about 4.4×, average rank climbed from 14.0 to 6.5, but clicks fell from 101,890 to 94,167; TrustMRR separately lists MRR at $189,610 and 63 subscriptions.

AEO Engine helps brands win citations in AI search. Its website features a customer case study whose page title says +341%. Click through and you get Broadview Federal Credit Union’s Google Search Console data: in February 2026, 1,571,580 impressions, 101,890 organic clicks, and an average position of 14.0; in September 2026, 6,924,673 impressions, 94,167 clicks, and an average position of 6.5.[1]

Figure: Source AEO Engine original image source[2], retrieved 2026-11-10; original interface preserved.

The average position moved from the middle of page two back to page one, impressions rose to about 4.4×, and clicks instead fell by more than seven thousand. Put those three numbers side by side, and they make clearer than any slogan what kind of trouble this company is dealing with: the top of the search results page is increasingly occupied by answers AI gives directly, and ranking high does not guarantee that anyone clicks through. AEO stands for answer engine optimization, but first look at what it actually does: content is generated according to topic maps and keyword strategy, the client approves the content calendar, and the team handles execution and monitoring; at the same time, the client has to hand over GA4, GSC, CMS, and technical access. Then a contract that starts at 90 days, bills monthly, and does not refund writes search traffic growth into a backstop clause.

What the client hands over is access

What has to be handed over is specific. Under the website’s 90-day traffic growth guarantee, qualified Growth/Scale clients must provide Google Analytics 4 (GA4), Google Search Console (GSC), CMS, and technical access in the first week. In the content publishing workflow, the client approves the content calendar; audits, entity optimization, structured data, answer-oriented content, and authority building are done together by “senior strategists, SEO experts, and more than 40 AI agents.”About AEO Engine[3] Pricing[4] The writing part goes to AI Blog Writer: the input is a keyword library or a custom topic plus a publishing schedule; after the system completes research and writing, it publishes directly to the CMS by default, then automatically submits to Google, Bing, and Yandex; before publishing, a human can also edit through Preview & Edit.[5]

More than 40 agents handle volume; strategists handle judgment. In the default workflow, what the client approves is the content calendar, and individual pieces can still be changed through Preview & Edit before publishing. That division of labor determines that what it sells is “someone gets it done for you,” not “a better editor.”

When the pricing page was captured on 2026-11-14, it listed three tiers: Growth at $1,597 per month and Scale at $2,997 per month, both with an initial term of 90 days, billed monthly, then renewing on a rolling six-month basis with 30 days’ written notice before renewal; there is no arbitrary early termination during the commitment period. Enterprise requires a call and custom pricing, and the terms state that the monthly fee starts at $10,000.[4] · [6]

All fees are non-refundable except as expressly stated in the terms or required by law; paying six or twelve months in advance gets a 10% or 15% discount, and the discount corresponds to paying for the whole term up front, not to lowering the monthly list price.

How much money has come in? There is a third-party page for reference. A record updated by TrustMRR at 2026-11-14 02:04 AM shows AEO Engine’s monthly recurring revenue (MRR) at $189,610, with 63 active subscriptions and $2,739,580 in cumulative historical revenue; the page says the revenue is verified through a Stripe API key. The page title separately lists revenue for the last 30 days at $165,851, which is a different measure from MRR.TrustMRR[7] The page does not say whether the revenue data covers all collections, nor does it disclose delivery costs, refunds, or the actual cost of waiving management fees and continuing work when the 90-day target is missed. MRR is not profit, and how the 63 subscriptions split among Growth, Scale, and Enterprise is likewise not disclosed, so what can be said now is only the revenue scale; profit remains unclear.

The line in the case study that did not keep up

Back to Broadview. What is most worth looking at is not +341%, but the line that did not keep up: impressions rose from 1.57 million to 6.92 million, while clicks kept fluctuating between 86,600 and 114,991, and September was still below February. The case study attributes 521 articles that brought impressions, 24.1 million impressions, and 46% of page-level total impressions to the content engine—“The content engine did most of that work.” But it does not map a given month’s ranking change to a specific change, nor does it offer a counterfactual, so this is a statement of contribution, not proof of causation.

The AI scorecard is smaller. The case study uses a snapshot from 2026-10-04: 150 credit-union and bank-related questions, four engines, 600 answers in total; the brand was mentioned in at least one engine’s answer for 8% of the questions, up from 5.3% in September; there were 22 citations in total, 14 of them from the mortgage and youth savings pages. The 8% is only one cross-section; the mentioned rate and the 22 citations are what the case study provides, and the methodology also lists share of voice and peer comparison.

There is another detail in the case study that the company itself flagged: the rise from 60,867 to 101,746/28 days in tracked form interactions is a tracked target event, not submitted leads; tracking only began on 2026-05-18, and the earliest complete 28-day window is not a pre-participation baseline. They wrote that sentence; no one else picked it out.

So the clause in the contract that is most likely to reassure people deserves a close read: for eligible Growth/Scale clients, measured against the prior 90-day GA4/GSC baseline, qualified organic search and AI search traffic must increase by 30% within 90 days; if it falls short, management fees are waived and work continues until the target is met. The conditions are not light—hand over GA4, GSC, CMS, and technical access in the first week, do not block content, technical fixes, and reasonable approvals, and during the period there must be no major migration, tracking failure, or sitewide redesign that wipes out the baseline.[4]

This guarantee measures “traffic.” In Broadview’s case, what rose was impressions; clicks did not increase in step. The two things are not contradictory: average position went from 14.0 to 6.5, and impressions naturally surged; but for the person paying, what they ultimately want is usually someone filling out a form or calling. The case study reports AI mention rate separately, while the contract backstop is traffic—neither line is that number yet.

The name is new; the business is not

The company information section is economical: legal name AEO Engine LLC, Founded 2018, roots trace back to FosterFBA, and it only began operating formally under the AEO Engine name in January 2026. The team section has only two people: Founder & CEO Vijay C. Jacob and Co-Founder & CMO Dan Ashburn.[3]

The website gives titles, résumés, and company history, but it does not explain why the company went from FosterFBA to AEO Engine. The fact that it takes only 5 new clients per month does come with a reason: the pricing page says this is to give each client custom setup and dedicated attention, and to make clients leaders in their niche.Pricing[4] The shape that can be confirmed is this: delivery is managed by people; Growth/Scale contracts start with a 90-day initial term and then renew on a rolling six-month basis; the backstop is waiving management fees and continuing until the target is met. All three things look more like a services company than a self-serve tool.

Compare it with SEObot and it becomes clearer. SEObot’s website calls itself a “fully automated SEO AI agent,” with monthly subscriptions starting at $49; it researches the website, audience, and keywords, lays out a content plan, and produces drafts every week, and users can approve, reject, or review them.SEObot[8] When it connects to WordPress.org, it needs a username with the Editor or Administrator role and an Application Password, not the login password; WordPress.com uses redirect authorization, and the plugin is another way to connect.[9]

So the difference is not “whether you hand over access,” but who makes judgments by default: SEObot can let you review drafts or publish automatically; with AEO Engine, the client approves the content calendar, individual pieces can still be changed, and day-to-day judgment is taken over by strategists; if the target is missed during the 90-day guarantee period, the team waives management fees and keeps working. Part of the price gap buys human judgment.

On the customer-acquisition side, only one entry point and one pitch are visible. The pricing page says the company takes only 5 new clients per month, and at the time of capture it showed only 2 spots left this month; there is also a 30-minute strategy call with no commitment and no credit card, plus a custom AI visibility report or growth roadmap.Pricing[4] The cap and the scarcity language can both be true, but there is no data here on channel sources, customer acquisition cost (CAC), conversion from booking to payment, or sales cycle, so it is impossible to judge the actual binding force of this cap.

What AEO Engine sells is a contract that takes over the content calendar, publishing, and GA4/GSC access, and it is responsible for one measurable search traffic line. The smartest part of this business is that it splits visibility into several lines that can be reported separately. The case study itself says this is so that growth in one area cannot hide weakness in another; it did indeed write the click decline into the report. But the same structure has another side: when clicks do not rise, the company can still bring out impressions, rankings, AI mention rate, and tracked forms to keep reporting progress. Sooner or later, clients will translate these lines back into the same question: have the times it was seen turned into real inquiries and phone calls?

Continue reading

AI search
He Treated Reddit as a Survey. 135,000 People Used It for Research. In 2025, It Stopped at a License

Fed built GummySearch into a tool for audience research using public Reddit discussions: it searched and tracked community conversations by categories such as pain points and people seeking solutions. After commercial licensing talks with Reddit failed, he chose to stop sales on November 30, 2025, and gradually shut down the site rather than continue operating without a license; paying users kept transitional access, and the free tier retained only login, export, and account deletion.

AI publishingAI writingAI imagesAI video
Do Not Start From a Blank Page: CaptureFlow Catches What You Say; the Signature Is Still Yours

CaptureFlow catches expression from voice, links, video, or files and hands it to Content Agent to draft; only after the user revises and explicitly approves does it publish to LinkedIn, and responsibility remains with the person. Chris Koronowski runs the company in Poznań, Poland, charging in three tiers—Pro, Business, and Agency—with the latter two priced by seat; a case study says InStream has 100 paid seats, while TrustMRR separately shows 8 subscriptions, and the two cannot be combined into a customer count.

AI supportAI searchAI commerce
When a Visitor Clicks Handoff to a Human, Chat Data Sends a Colleague an Email with a Login-Free Link

Chat Data trains company documents, webpages, and files into an AI customer-service agent that can be deployed to websites and messaging channels, and uses a login-free email link to connect visitors who ask for a human. It charges by message credit and supports custom models and MCP hosted by Composio; the TrustMRR page lists MRR of 17,645 US dollars and 304 active subscriptions, with a team of 2–5 people.

AI supportAI searchAI commerce
Customer Support Bots Start Looking Up Orders for You, and Chatwith Bills “Talking” and “Acting” Separately

Chatwith bills customer-support answers and external actions separately: messages use credits, while actions successfully executed through MCP are billed separately; plans start at 9 US dollars, and an extra 1,000 MCP actions cost 6 US dollars. The founder says he put about 21,000 US dollars of AppSumo revenue into Google Ads in 2024 and at one point a Google Ads bill went unpaid; TrustMRR shows MRR of 3,622 US dollars and 42 active subscriptions in November 2026.